Where the numbers come from
Trade-in desks and used retailers are checked regularly. Every figure keeps its source, price basis, condition, and the date we checked it.
We check 10 trade-in desks. Desks that always give the same offer count as one independent opinion.
Used asking prices come from active listings at used retailers and marketplaces. Sold prices come from completed eBay sales: Buy It Now and auction results only, since a Best Offer sale shows the price before the offer.
| Desk | Pays in |
|---|---|
| 2nd Swing | Store credit and cash |
| Callaway Pre-Owned | Store credit |
| GlobalGolf | Store credit |
| Golf Blue Book | Store credit and cash |
| Golf Club Brokers | Cash |
| iGolf Value Guide | Cash |
| Next Round | Store credit |
| PGA Value Guide | Store credit and cash |
| Rock Bottom Golf | Store credit and cash |
| TGW | Store credit |
Four kinds of price, never mixed
Store credit, cash, used asking and sold prices never get mixed together. Each figure names its kind and is drawn in its color, and no total adds one kind to another.
Store credit
What a trade-in desk offers you to spend in its own shop. Offers are current quotes, not final: the shop inspects the club before it pays.
Cash
What a trade-in desk pays you in money for the same club. It is shown apart from store credit, never averaged with it.
Used asking
What used retailers list the club for. The typical asking price is the median active listing for the selected condition once at least 5 comparable listings exist. An asking price is not a completed sale.
Sold
The middle eligible completed sale, pooled across every used grade. We publish it once at least 3 sales qualify and show the dates of the first and last sale behind it; sales can reach back 90 days.
Condition grades
A club page shows the condition you pick, starting at Average. Prices stay separate by grade: a quote for one grade is never shown as another's.
Brand, club type, family, year and search pages compare store credit at average condition, so every row answers the same question. A model with no average quote shows no credit there rather than a figure from another grade.
The home page's most traded clubs are the exception: each shows its best current offer at any grade, with the grade beside it.
- New in box
- Unused and still sealed in its original packaging.
- New
- Unused, with no visible play wear.
- Mint
- Nearly new, with minimal signs of handling or play.
- Above average
- Light marks on the face and sole, with no dents or sky marks.
- Good
- Normal play wear, with no damage that affects performance.
- AverageCompared on collection pages
- Visible wear from regular use, but fully playable.
- Below average
- Heavy wear, paint chips or sky marks, but still playable.
- Poor
- Significant cosmetic wear or damage that may affect playability.
- Not specified
- The seller did not publish enough detail to assign a grade.
When we checked
We check prices every night, and the site changes over to the new prices all at once.
Every figure carries the date we checked it, with the year when the check is from an earlier year. We give the date rather than a relative time, so a figure reads the same whenever you open the page.
An older offer keeps its place in the ranking with the date we checked it beside it, and it is never called the best offer.
Missing is never zero
When no desk quotes your club, we say so. We never fill the gap with a guess.
Missing quotes stay missing and are never converted into zero-dollar values. A club with no quote at one grade shows no number there, not the nearest grade's.
When a shop isn't quoting a club, the club page says why when we know: it quotes a different grade, or not this hand or configuration.
A figure resting on only a few listings or sales says how many, and a chart or change waits until there is enough history to compare like with like.
Bonuses count only when verified
A trade-in bonus is added to an offer only when we have verified its terms and it applies to that club, grade and payout. Until then it is shown beside the offer and never added in.
A bonus published as “up to” a percentage is never applied as a rate, and a bonus that only counts toward a purchase is never added to a cash offer.
How sure we are
Confidence measures the evidence behind a price, not the club's condition or where its price will go.
- High
- At least 3 independent opinions and 20 comparable listings.
- Medium
- At least 2 independent opinions or 5 listings.
- Low
- Only one independent opinion, or fewer than 5 listings.
- Not enough yet
- No desk quotes the club and no retailer lists it.
Other terms
- Independent opinions
- Desks that always give the same offer count as one independent opinion, so two desks quoting the same number are not two confirmations.
- Value kept
- A model's typical used asking price as a share of its launch price, what it sold for new at launch: the maker's own price where we have it, else what retailers charged new when we first tracked it, else an estimate from Golf Blue Book's list price.
- Deal ratings
- Each listing's price against the typical used asking for the same model and condition: below typical, a typical price, or above typical. A listing is rated only when at least 5 comparable listings back the typical price.
- Most traded
- Ranked by shops quoting and listings for sale, not page views.
- Model year
- Our reconciled assignment, not always an announcement date. Where sources disagree, the club page says so.
How we rank
We rank by offer only. Store credit and cash offers are ranked separately, each by amount.
Offers sort by what you would receive. No shop can pay for a higher spot.