Golf retailers compared
Who pays the most, who has the most for sale and who has the deals. Checked Nov 19.
Best for store credit
Models where it pays the most credit, at Average
- Rank 1: 2nd Swing6,922
- Rank 2: Rock Bottom Golf3,702
- Rank 3: PGA Value Guide in 2nd Swing credit1,902
Best for cash
Models where it pays the most cash, at Average
- Rank 1: PGA Value Guide5,628
- Rank 2: Golf Club Brokers3,940
- Rank 3: Rock Bottom Golf2,799
- Rank 4: iGolf Value Guide2,645
- Rank 5: 2nd Swing1,658
Most for sale
Current listings we check
- Rank 1: 2nd Swing114,838
- Rank 2: GlobalGolf20,140
- Rank 3: Golf Avenue16,612
- Rank 4: Callaway Pre-Owned13,367
- Rank 5: SidelineSwap6,453
Most deals
Listings $100+ under typical
- Rank 1: Callaway Pre-Owned560
- Rank 2: GlobalGolf326
- Rank 3: 2nd Swing154
- Rank 4: SidelineSwap153
- Rank 5: Golf Club Brokers36
Every retailer, side by side
Terms from each retailer's published pages
- 2nd SwingCredit and cash · $9.99 label · 114,838 for sale · +15% drivers
- PGA Value GuideCash, or 2nd Swing credit
- Rock Bottom GolfCredit and cash · 1,722 for sale
- Golf Club BrokersCash · 1,506 for sale
- iGolf Value GuideCash
- GlobalGolfCredit · free label · 20,140 for sale · 3 sales · 2 shipping offers
- Callaway Pre-OwnedCredit · 13,367 for sale
- Next RoundCredit · $9.99, free over $100 label · 3,390 for sale · 1 trade-in bonus
- TGWCredit · $8.99 label · 2,570 for sale
- Golf Blue BookCredit and cash
- Golf Avenue16,612 for sale
- SidelineSwap6,453 for sale
- Golf Discount4,574 for sale · 1 shipping offer
- Worldwide Golf Shops3,122 for sale
- Golf Direct Now2,280 for sale
- Carl's Golfland767 for sale · 1 shipping offer
- Mike's Golf Outlet113 for sale
- Fairway Golf USA - Pre-Owned19 for sale
- Fairway Golf USA - New13 for sale
| Retailer | Buys clubs for | Shipping label | For sale | Current offers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2nd Swing | Credit and cash | $9.99 | 114,838 | +15% drivers |
| PGA Value Guide | Cash, or 2nd Swing credit | Not published | None | None |
| Rock Bottom Golf | Credit and cash | Not published | 1,722 | None |
| Golf Club Brokers | Cash | Not published | 1,506 | None |
| iGolf Value Guide | Cash | Not published | None | None |
| GlobalGolf | Credit | Free | 20,140 | 3 sales · 2 shipping offers |
| Callaway Pre-Owned | Credit | Not published | 13,367 | None |
| Next Round | Credit | $9.99, free over $100 | 3,390 | 1 trade-in bonus |
| TGW | Credit | $8.99 | 2,570 | None |
| Golf Blue Book | Credit and cash | Not published | None | None |
| Golf Avenue | None | None | 16,612 | None |
| SidelineSwap | None | None | 6,453 | None |
| Golf Discount | None | None | 4,574 | 1 shipping offer |
| Worldwide Golf Shops | None | None | 3,122 | None |
| Golf Direct Now | None | None | 2,280 | None |
| Carl's Golfland | None | None | 767 | 1 shipping offer |
| Mike's Golf Outlet | None | None | 113 | None |
| Fairway Golf USA - Pre-Owned | None | None | 19 | None |
| Fairway Golf USA - New | None | None | 13 | None |
Where should you trade in golf clubs?
For store credit, 2nd Swing pays the most on the most models we check: 6,922 at Average on Nov 19. For cash, PGA Value Guide leads on 5,628. The best shop for one club can differ, so check its page before you ship.
Common questions
Which golf trade-in site pays the most?
It depends on the club. Across the models we check at Average, 2nd Swing pays the most store credit on 6,922 and PGA Value Guide the most cash on 5,628.
Which sites pay cash for golf clubs?
2nd Swing, Golf Blue Book, Golf Club Brokers, iGolf Value Guide, PGA Value Guide and Rock Bottom Golf.
Do trade-in sites charge for the shipping label?
2nd Swing takes $9.99 from the offer, Next Round takes $9.99 from the offer (waived at $100 or more) and TGW takes $8.99 from the offer. GlobalGolf's label is free.