

Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 Putter Used price and trade-in value
Used Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 Putter for sale. Compare current used listings and asking prices.
Offers are for this model and grade. Listings match your configuration
The market for this club
Right hand, Average. Checked Nov 18.
Launch price $750 in 2025. Scotty Cameron's suggested retail price. From Titleist's press release, July 2025. Best cash $256, PGA Value Guide.
- Checked Nov 18
- For this model and grade. The final amount depends on their inspection
- Opens 2nd Swing's trade-in form with this club selected, not a saved quote
- Choose โAverageโ for condition on their form
- Listing checked Nov 18
2 desks quote this model at your grade. 1 live listing at 1 retailer.
Price history
- Used asking
- Trade credit
- Cash
Used asking holding over 7 daysTrade credit holding over 7 days
Trade credit holding over 30 days
67 nights tracked since Sep 9. Grey dots are days a different set of shops quoted, so they are not compared with the latest check. Grey bands are nights with no prices on record. Grey dots are days a different set of shops quoted, so they are not compared with the latest check.
| Day | Used asking | Trade credit | Cash |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9 | $594, other shops | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Sep 10 | No comparable check | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Sep 11 | No comparable check | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 12 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Sep 13 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Sep 14 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Sep 15 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 16 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 17 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 18 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 19 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 20 | No comparable check | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 21 | $567, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 22 | No comparable check | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 23 | No comparable check | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 24 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 25 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 26 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 27 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 28 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 29 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Sep 30 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 1 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 2 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 3 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 4 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 5 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 6 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 7 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 8 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 9 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 10 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 11 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 12 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 13 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 14 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 15 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 16 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 17 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 18 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 19 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 20 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 21 | $594, other shops | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 22 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Oct 23 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Oct 24 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Oct 25 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Oct 26 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check |
| Oct 27 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Oct 28 | $594 | $269, other shops | $242, other shops |
| Oct 29 | $594 | $269, other shops | $242, other shops |
| Oct 30 | $594 | $269, other shops | $242, other shops |
| Oct 31 | $594 | $269, other shops | $242, other shops |
| Nov 1 | $594 | $269, other shops | $242, other shops |
| Nov 2 | No comparable check | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 3 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 4 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 5 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 6 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 7 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 8 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 9 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 10 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 11 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 12 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 13 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 14 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 15 | $594 | $269 | $256, other shops |
| Nov 16 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 17 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 18 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
| Nov 19 | $594 | $269 | $256 |
Sell or trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 putter
2 desks quote this model at Average. The best is $269 in store credit at 2nd Swing; the best cash is $256 at PGA Value Guide.
Who will buy it from you
Ranked by store credit. Desks cannot pay for placement.
- 2nd SwingCredit and cash$269
Their terms
$9.99 label taken from the offer
From 2nd Swing's published terms, checked Sep 26.
Cash $242 ยท For this model and gradeChecked Nov 18For this model and gradeChecked Nov 18 - PGA Value GuideCredit and cash$269Cash $256 ยท For this model and gradeChecked Nov 16For this model and gradeChecked Nov 16
Ranked by offer amount only. Desks cannot pay for placement. Final offers depend on inspection.
Desks that don't quote this model in average condition
- Callaway Pre-OwnedQuotes without a grade
- Next RoundNo current offer
- GlobalGolfDoesn't list this model
- Golf Blue BookDoesn't list this model
- Golf Club BrokersDoesn't list this model
- Rock Bottom GolfDoesn't list this model
- TGWDoesn't list this model
- iGolf Value GuideDoesn't list this model
Trade it in or sell it yourself?
- Trade for store credit at 2nd Swing$259After a $9.99 shipping label
- Sell for cash at PGA Value Guide$256Before the shipping label, which isn't on record
- Sell it yourself on eBayFewer than 3 recent salesFewer than 3 recent sales
Store credit by grade
The best store credit at each grade
- New in boxNo desk quotes this grade
- NewNo desk quotes this grade
- MintNo desk quotes this grade
- Above averageNo desk quotes this grade
- Below averageNo desk quotes this grade
- PoorNo desk quotes this grade
Buy a used Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 putter
1 listing at 1 retailer matches your configuration. The lowest listing is $540 at 2nd Swing Golf.
For sale now
One in stock
- Average, checked Nov 18AverageChecked Nov 18$540
Used asking by grade
The typical used asking price at each grade
- New in boxNo listings
- NewNo listings
- Mint$621
- Above average$594
- Below averageNo listings
- PoorNo listings
Average means: visible wear from regular use, but fully playable.
Reviews of the Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 putter
Below: what golfers on Face Value think.
Would you recommend it?
Golfers on Face Value, on the Phantom Black 5.5.
One tap to vote.
More putters from Scotty Cameron
- Gold Plated Victory
- Phantom 7.2 2024
- Studio Style Catalina
- Studio Style Fastback 2025
- Studio Style Fastback Long Design 2025
- Studio Style Fastback Long Design
- Studio Style Fastback
- Studio Style Newport 2 2025
- Studio Style Newport 2.5 Plus 2025
- Studio Style Newport 2.5 Plus
- Studio Style Newport 2 Plus
- Studio Style Newport Plus
- Studio Style Newport Tour
- Studio Style Squareback 2 Long Design
- Studio Style Squareback 2
- Studio Style Squareback 2025
- Studio Style Squareback
- Studio Xperimental Fastback 2
- Studio Xperimental Squareback 2
- B3 Triple Black Limited Newport 2 Longneck
- B3 Triple Black Limited Newport 2
- Masterful Buttonback
- Phantom 11.5
- Phantom 11R OC Circle T
- Phantom 11R OC Spec III
- Phantom 12
- Phantom 3.2
- Phantom 5 OC
- Phantom 5 OC Spec III
- Phantom 7 DB
- Phantom 9.2R
- Phantom 9.5R
- Phantom 9R
- Phantom X 11 Long
- Studio Style FastBack 2 Long Design 2026
- Studio Style Fastback 2
- Studio Style Santa Fe 2026
- Studio Style Santa Fe
- Tour Fastback TFB
- Tour Squareback TSB Black
More clubs from 2025
- W1
- PTX Max
- PTX Max
- PTX Max
- Antidote SB1
- Antidote SB2 Long
- Antidote SB3
- Antidote SB5
- HLX 6.0 Forged Chrome
- HLX 6.0 Forged Graphite
- Queen B 14
- Queen B 16
- Queen B 7
- Paradox Blade
- Paradox Blade
- Paradox Mallet
- Classic 72
- Apex 26 UT
- Apex Ai150
- Apex Ti Super
- Apex UW 2025
- APEX UW
- CB 12
- CB12
- Elyte
- Elyte
- Elyte HL
- Elyte
- ELYTE MAX FAST
- ELYTE MAX FAST
- ELYTE MAX FAST
- Elyte Max Fast
- ELYTE MINI
- Elyte Mini Night Edition
- ELYTE NIGHT EDITION
- Elyte Sandstorm
- ELYTE SANDSTORM TRIPLE DIAMOND
- Elyte Sandstorm Triple Diamond Max
- Elyte Ti
- ELYTE TITANIUM
- Elyte TOUR
- ELYTE TRIPLE DIAMOND
Related models
- Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 7 Putter
- Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 11 Putter
- Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 9.2R Putter
- Scotty Cameron Phantom 11R OC Putter
- Scotty Cameron Studio Style Fastback OC Putter
- Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.2 Putter
- Scotty Cameron Studio Style Fastback 1.5 Putter
- Scotty Cameron Phantom 7.2 Putter
What is a Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 putter worth?
A used Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 putter in average condition lists for $540 across 1 current listing, too few for a typical price. The best trade-in offer is $269 in store credit from 2nd Swing and the best cash offer is $256 from PGA Value Guide, both checked Nov 18.
The Phantom Black 5.5 arrived in 2025 as part of Scotty Cameron's Phantom Black (2025) family.
Common questions
How much can I trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 for?
Up to $269 in store credit at 2nd Swing, or $256 cash at PGA Value Guide, for a right-handed putter in average condition. The shop sets the final amount after inspecting the club.
How much does a used Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 cost?
Used asking runs $540 in average condition, from too few listings for a typical price. The lowest listing, checked Nov 18, is $540 at 2nd Swing Golf.
Does condition change what a Scotty Cameron Phantom Black 5.5 is worth?
Yes. Typical used asking by grade: Mint $621, Above average $594 and Average $540.