Used Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 Putter for sale. Compare current used listings and asking prices.
Offers are for this model and grade. Listings match your configuration
The market for this club
Right hand, Average. Checked Nov 18.
Best cash $211, PGA Value Guide. Sold on eBay for a median of $275 across 3 recent sales.
- Checked Nov 18
- For this model and grade. The final amount depends on their inspection
- Opens 2nd Swing's trade-in form with this club selected, not a saved quote
- Choose “Average” for condition on their form
- At the typical asking price
- Listing checked Nov 18
3 desks quote this model at your grade. 5 live listings at 2 retailers.
Price history
- Used asking
- Trade credit
- Cash
- Sold on eBay
- New
Used asking holding over 7 daysTrade credit holding over 7 days
Used asking holding over 30 daysTrade credit holding over 30 days
67 nights tracked since Sep 9. Grey bands are nights with no prices on record. Grey dots are days a different set of shops quoted, so they are not compared with the latest check.
| Day | Used asking | Trade credit | Cash | Sold on eBay |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9 | $429, other shops | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Sep 10 | No comparable check | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 11 | No comparable check | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 12 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Sep 13 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Sep 14 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Sep 15 | $439 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 16 | $439 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 17 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 18 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 19 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 20 | No comparable check | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 21 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 22 | No comparable check | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 23 | No comparable check | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 24 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Sep 25 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | $500 |
| Sep 26 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Sep 27 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Sep 28 | $429 | $222 | $93 | $275 |
| Sep 29 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Sep 30 | $429 | $222 | $93 | $270 |
| Oct 1 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 2 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 3 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 4 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 5 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 6 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 7 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 8 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 9 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 10 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 11 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 12 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 13 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 14 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 15 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 16 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 17 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 18 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 19 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 20 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 21 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Oct 22 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Oct 23 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Oct 24 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Oct 25 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Oct 26 | No comparable check | No comparable check | No comparable check | None |
| Oct 27 | $429 | $222, other shops | $211, other shops | None |
| Oct 28 | $429 | $222, other shops | $93 | None |
| Oct 29 | $429 | $222, other shops | $93 | None |
| Oct 30 | $429 | $222, other shops | $93 | None |
| Oct 31 | $429 | $222, other shops | $93 | None |
| Nov 1 | $429 | $222, other shops | $93 | None |
| Nov 2 | No comparable check | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 3 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 4 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 5 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 6 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 7 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 8 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 9 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 10 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 11 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 12 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 13 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 14 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 15 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 16 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 17 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 18 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
| Nov 19 | $429 | $222 | $93 | None |
Sell or trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 putter
3 desks quote this model at Average. The best is $222 in store credit at 2nd Swing; the best cash is $211 at PGA Value Guide.
Who will buy it from you
Ranked by store credit. Desks cannot pay for placement.
- 2nd SwingCredit and cash$222
Their terms
$9.99 label taken from the offer
From 2nd Swing's published terms, checked Sep 26.
Cash $200 · For this model and gradeChecked Nov 18For this model and gradeChecked Nov 18 - PGA Value GuideCredit and cash$222Cash $211 · For this model and gradeChecked Nov 16For this model and gradeChecked Nov 16
- Rock Bottom GolfCredit and cash$102Cash $93 · For this model and gradeChecked Nov 17For this model and gradeChecked Nov 17
Ranked by offer amount only. Desks cannot pay for placement. Final offers depend on inspection.
Desks that don't quote this model in average condition
- Next RoundQuotes New, Above average and Below average only
- Callaway Pre-OwnedDoesn't list this model
- GlobalGolfDoesn't list this model
- Golf Blue BookDoesn't list this model
- Golf Club BrokersDoesn't list this model
- TGWDoesn't list this model
- iGolf Value GuideDoesn't list this model
Trade it in or sell it yourself?
- Trade for store credit at PGA Value Guide$222Before the shipping label, which isn't on record
- Sell for cash at PGA Value Guide$211Before the shipping label, which isn't on record
- Sell it yourself on eBay$222$275 sold median, less $38 in eBay fees and $15 shipping
Store credit by grade
The best store credit at each grade
- New in boxNo desk quotes this grade
- New$220
- MintNo desk quotes this grade
- Above average$190
- Below average$135
- Poor$5
Above average gets about $32 less in store credit than Average, and Below average about $87 less.
Each grade down takes about $87 to $130 off the best store credit, from Average to Poor.
Buy a used Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 putter
5 listings at 2 retailers match your configuration. The lowest listing is $390 at 2nd Swing Golf, at the typical asking price.
For sale now
5 in stock
- Average, checked Nov 18AverageChecked Nov 18$390Typical price
Titleist Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom 5.5 Putter Steel Right Handed 35.0in
2nd Swing Golf · Listed 62 daysAverage, checked Nov 18AverageChecked Nov 18$390Typical priceTitleist Scotty Cameron 2026 Phantom 5.5 Putter Steel Right Handed 32.5in
2nd Swing Golf · Listed 68 daysAverage, checked Nov 18AverageChecked Nov 18$390Typical priceScotty Cameron 2026 Phantom 5.5 36" Jet-Neck Mallet Putter w/SuperStroke & HC
SidelineSwap · Listed 1 dayAverage, checked Nov 13AverageChecked Nov 13$520Above typicalUsed Scotty Cameron PHANTOM 5.5 PUTTER Mens Putter RH 11834-S000059402
SidelineSwap · Listed 3 daysAverage, checked Nov 13AverageChecked Nov 13$535Above typical
Used asking by grade
The typical used asking price at each grade
- New in boxNo listings
- New$549
- Mint$449
- Above average$429
- Below averageNo listings
- PoorNo listings
Above average lists for about $39 more than Average.
Each grade down takes about $20 to $100 off the used asking price, from New to Above average.
Average means: visible wear from regular use, but fully playable.
Reviews of the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 putter
Below: what golfers on Face Value think.
Would you recommend it?
Golfers on Face Value, on the Phantom 5.5.
One tap to vote.
Older and newer versions
Trade credit and used asking in the same condition. Share of launch price shows where a launch price is on record.
Each bar runs from the best store credit to the typical used asking. All 3 share one scale, up to $400 in used asking, so a bar farther right is a pricier generation.Each bar runs from best store credit to typical used asking, on one scale. The black tick is this club's typical used asking, $390.
The newest, Phantom (2025), lists for $87 less used.
- Phantom (2024)2024 · This club
$235$390 - H24 Limited Phantom (2024)2024$341
- Phantom (2025)2025 · Newest
$247$303
More putters from Scotty Cameron
- Champions Choice Newport Plus
- Champions Choice NP 1.5 Plus
- Champions Choice NP 2 Plus
- Concept X 7.2 LTD
- Masterful TourType SSS Circle T
- Phantom 11
- Phantom T 7.5
- Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus
- Super Select Newport 2 Plus
- Super Select Newport Plus
- Tour T-11 Proto
- TourType SSS F-3
- TourType SSS F-5
- TourType SSS Masterful+
- TourType SSS SB-2 Circle T
- TourType SSS Timeless
- B3 Triple Black Limited Newport 2 Longneck
- B3 Triple Black Limited Newport 2
- H12 Jet Setter Limited Edition
- Jet Set Newport 2 Plus Limited
- Masterful Buttonback
- Phantom X 11 Long
- Phantom X 5 2022
- Phantom X 5.5 2022
- Phantom X 7 2022
- Phantom X 9
- Super Select Del Mar
- Super Select Fastback 1.5
- Super Select GOLO 6.5
- Super Select GOLO 6
- Super Select Newport
- Super Select Squareback 2
- Teryllium TNP Cirlcle T
- Tour Fastback TFB
- Tour Squareback TSB Black
- Tour Timeless Circle T
- Xperimental Golo 6.2 Limited
- Gold Plated Victory
- Justin Thomas Phantom X 5.5
- Masterful Super Rat 1 Tour
More clubs from 2023
- IDEA
- 25th Anniversary SS8 Slant
- BB28 Armlock
- BB28 Center Shaft
- BB28
- BB43 XXV
- HLX 5.0 Forged Black
- INOVAI 6.0 SLANT NECK
- Inovai 6.5 Spud Limited Run
- Queen B 15
- SS17 Thompson Limited Run
- Studio B Reserve QB14
- Studio Stock 14 Jumbo
- Studio Stock 14
- Studio Stock 16
- Studio Stock 35
- Studio Stock 9 Plumber's Neck
- Studio Stock 9 Plumbers Neck
- Studio Stock 9 Spud Neck
- Studio Stock 9 Spud
- Studio Stock 9 Spudneck
- 04
- x1
- Apex Pro 24
- Apex UT 2024
- Apex UW 24
- Big Bertha 2023
- Big Bertha 2023
- BIG BERTHA 23
- Big Bertha 23
- Big Bertha 23
- Big Bertha 23
- Big Bertha REVA 2023
- BIG BERTHA REVA 23
- Big Bertha REVA 23
- Big Bertha REVA 23
- Big Bertha REVA 23
- CB 2023
- CB
- Great Big Bertha 2023
- JAWS Raw Chrome Full Toe J Grind
- JAWS Raw Chrome J Grind
What is a Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 putter worth?
A used Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 putter in average condition has a typical asking price of $390 across 5 current listings at 2 retailers. The best trade-in offer is $222 in store credit from 2nd Swing and the best cash offer is $211 from PGA Value Guide, both checked Nov 18. On eBay it has sold for a median of $275 across 3 recent sales.
The Phantom 5.5 arrived in 2023 as part of Scotty Cameron's Phantom (2024) family. Used, it lists for $87 more than the newest Phantom (2025) in the same condition.
Selling it yourself on eBay nets $222 after $38 in fees and $15 shipping, against $222 in store credit from 2nd Swing. Store credit only spends at the shop that pays it, so weigh the cash offer if you aren't buying there.
Common questions
How much can I trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 for?
Up to $222 in store credit at 2nd Swing, or $211 cash at PGA Value Guide, for a right-handed putter in average condition. The shop sets the final amount after inspecting the club.
How much does a used Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 cost?
The typical used asking price is $390 in average condition. The lowest listing, checked Nov 18, is $390 at 2nd Swing Golf.
What has a Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 sold for?
A sold median of $275 across 3 eBay sales in the last 90 days. This is a sold price, not an asking price.
How does it compare with the Phantom (2025)?
Used, the Phantom (2025) lists for $303 against $390 for this club in the same condition.
Does condition change what a Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5 is worth?
Yes. Typical used asking by grade: New $549, Mint $449, Above average $429 and Average $390. Each grade down takes about $20 to $100 off the used asking price, from New to Above average.