Skip to content

Offers are for this model and grade. Listings match your configuration

The market for this club

Right hand, Average. Checked Nov 17.

Typical used askingNo used listings to compare

Best cash $93, Rock Bottom Golf.

Best store credit offer
$102Store credit at Rock Bottom Golfholding over 7 days
  • Checked Nov 17
  • For this model and grade. The final amount depends on their inspection
  • Opens Rock Bottom Golf's trade-in form, not a saved quote
Get this offer (opens in a new tab)

Price history

  • Used asking
  • Trade credit
  • Cash
  • New

66 nights tracked since Sep 9.

Price history by day
DayUsed askingTrade creditCash
Sep 9No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 10No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 11No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 12No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 13No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 14No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 15No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 16No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 17No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 18No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 19No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 20No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 21No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 22No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 23No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 24No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 25No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Sep 26No comparable check$140$93
Sep 27No comparable check$140$93
Sep 28No comparable check$140$93
Sep 29No comparable check$140$93
Sep 30No comparable check$140$93
Oct 1No comparable check$140$93
Oct 2No comparable check$140$93
Oct 3No comparable check$140$93
Oct 4No comparable check$140$93
Oct 5No comparable check$140$93
Oct 6No comparable check$140$93
Oct 7$366, other shops$140$93
Oct 8$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 9$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 10$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 11$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 12$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 13$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 14$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 15$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 16$379, other shops$140$93
Oct 17$376, other shops$140$93
Oct 18No comparable check$140$93
Oct 19No comparable check$140$93
Oct 20No comparable check$140$93
Oct 21No comparable check$140$93
Oct 22No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 23No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 24No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 25No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 26No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 27No comparable checkNo comparable checkNo comparable check
Oct 28No comparable check$140$93
Oct 29No comparable check$140$93
Oct 30No comparable check$140$93
Oct 31No comparable check$140$93
Nov 1No comparable check$140$93
Nov 2No comparable check$140$93
Nov 3No comparable check$140$93
Nov 4No comparable check$102$93
Nov 5No comparable check$102$93
Nov 6No comparable check$102$93
Nov 7No comparable check$102$93
Nov 8No comparable check$102$93
Nov 9No comparable check$102$93
Nov 10No comparable check$102$93
Nov 11No comparable check$102$93
Nov 12No comparable check$102$93
Nov 13No comparable check$102$93
Nov 14No comparable check$102$93
Nov 15No comparable check$102$93
Nov 16No comparable check$102$93
Nov 17No comparable check$102$93
Nov 18No comparable check$102$93
Nov 19No comparable check$102$93

Sell or trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 putter

1 desk quotes this model at Average. The best is $102 in store credit at Rock Bottom Golf; the best cash is $93 at Rock Bottom Golf.

Who will buy it from you

Ranked by store credit. Desks cannot pay for placement.

  1. Rock Bottom GolfCredit and cash
    $102
    Cash $93 · For this model and gradeChecked Nov 17

Ranked by offer amount only. Desks cannot pay for placement. Final offers depend on inspection.

Desks that don't quote this model in average condition
  • 2nd SwingNo current offer
  • Next RoundNo current offer
  • Callaway Pre-OwnedDoesn't list this model
  • GlobalGolfDoesn't list this model
  • Golf Blue BookDoesn't list this model
  • Golf Club BrokersDoesn't list this model
  • PGA Value GuideDoesn't list this model
  • TGWDoesn't list this model
  • iGolf Value GuideDoesn't list this model

Trade it in or sell it yourself?

  • Trade for store credit at Rock Bottom Golf$102
    Before the shipping label, which isn't on record
  • Sell for cash at Rock Bottom Golf$93
    Before the shipping label, which isn't on record
  • Sell it yourself on eBay
    Fewer than 3 recent sales

Store credit by grade

The best store credit at each grade

  1. New$123
  2. Average$102
  3. Poor$5

New gets about $20 more in store credit than Average, and Poor about $97 less.

Buy a used Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 putter

For sale now

No listings for this configuration right now.

Used asking by grade

The typical used asking price at each grade

  1. New$449
  2. AverageNo listings
  3. PoorNo listings

Average means: visible wear from regular use, but fully playable.

Reviews of the Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 putter

Below: what golfers on Face Value think.

Community score

Would you recommend it?

Golfers on Face Value, on the Phantom 9.5.

One tap to vote.

Older and newer versions

Trade credit and used asking in the same condition. Share of launch price shows where a launch price is on record.

Each bar runs from best store credit to typical used asking, on one scale.

  1. 2024This clubPhantom (2024)The Phantom (2024) family, 8 models
  2. 2024H24 Limited Phantom (2024)
  3. 2025NewestPhantom (2025)
  1. Phantom (2024)2024 · This club
    $235$390
  2. H24 Limited Phantom (2024)2024
    $341
  3. Phantom (2025)2025 · Newest
    $247$303
Phantom (2024) used, two generations back129%of the newest Phantom (2025): $390 against $303
Phantom (2024) trade-in, two generations back95%of the Phantom (2025)'s best offer: $235 against $247

What is a Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 putter worth?

Common questions

How much can I trade in a Scotty Cameron Phantom 9.5 for?

Up to $102 in store credit at Rock Bottom Golf, or $93 cash at Rock Bottom Golf, for a right-handed putter in average condition. The shop sets the final amount after inspecting the club.